Kudos has partnered with CardRatings and Red Ventures for our coverage of credit card products. Kudos, CardRatings, and Red Ventures may receive a commission from card issuers. Kudos may receive commission from card issuers. Some of the card offers that appear on Kudos are from advertisers and may impact how and where card products appear on the site. Kudos tries to include as many card companies and offers as we are aware of, including offers from issuers that don't pay us, but we may not cover all card companies or all available card offers. You don't have to use our links, but we're grateful when you do!
AmEx Cell Phone Protection vs AppleCare+: Complete Guide 2025
July 1, 2025
.webp)
You just bought a new iPhone 16 Pro for $1,199. Within seconds of walking out of the Apple Store, the sales associate asks: "Would you like AppleCare+ for $13.49 per month?" You hesitate. That's $162 annually—on top of your $1,200 phone. Is it worth it?
Here's what most iPhone owners don't know: If you have certain American Express credit cards, you might already have cell phone protection that rivals AppleCare+—at no additional cost beyond your existing annual fee.
The surprising reality: Amex cell phone protection covers up to $800 per claim (up to $1,600 annually) with just a $50 deductible. AppleCare+, by comparison, costs $140-$162 per year and still requires deductibles of $29-$149 depending on the damage type. For many cardholders, that means Amex's free benefit could save $140+ annually while providing comparable coverage.
But there's a catch: Amex's protection isn't identical to AppleCare+. Understanding the specific differences—what's covered, what's excluded, and when each makes sense—determines whether you should skip AppleCare+ entirely or stack both protections for maximum coverage.
In this guide, you'll discover exactly how Amex cell phone protection works, which cards offer it, and whether AppleCare+'s added cost delivers enough extra value to justify the expense.
Understanding Amex Cell Phone Protection
What Is Amex Cell Phone Protection?
American Express cell phone protection is a complimentary benefit included with select credit cards that covers damage or theft to your cell phone—at no extra charge beyond your card's annual fee.
Key specifications:
- Coverage limit: Up to $800 per claim, $1,600 per 12-month period
- Deductible: $50 per claim
- Claims allowed: Two approved claims per 12-month period
- Activation requirement: Pay your monthly cell phone bill with an eligible Amex card
- Coverage type: Secondary coverage (excess of other insurance)
Terms apply to American Express benefits and offers. Enrollment may be required for select American Express benefits and offers. Visit americanexpress.com to learn more. Eligibility and Benefit level varies by Card. Terms, Conditions, and Limitations Apply. Please visit americanexpress.com/benefitsguide for more details. Underwritten by New Hampshire Insurance Company, an AIG Company.
How It Works: The Simple Activation Process
Step 1: Have an eligible American Express card
Step 2: Pay your entire monthly cell phone bill with that card (automatic payments work perfectly)
Step 3: Your phone is now automatically covered against:
- Accidental damage (drops, cracks, liquid damage)
- Screen damage (this is specifically covered—a rarity)
- Theft
Step 4: If damage or theft occurs, file a claim online at americanexpress.com
Real-world scenario: Sarah drops her iPhone 16 Pro, cracking the screen. The out-of-pocket repair at Apple costs $379. With Amex cell phone protection, she pays just a $50 deductible and gets reimbursed for the remaining $329. Total out-of-pocket: $50.
What Makes Amex Protection Unique
Screen damage coverage: Unlike many credit card insurance programs, Amex explicitly covers screen damage—the most common type of phone damage. This matters: screen repairs for iPhone 16 Pro models cost $379 without insurance.
Family coverage: The protection extends to all phone lines on your monthly bill, not just the primary account holder. If you have a family plan with four lines, all four phones are covered.
No enrollment required: Unlike some benefits that require registration, Amex cell phone protection activates automatically when you pay your bill with an eligible card.
Secondary coverage benefit: While "secondary coverage" sounds like a limitation, it actually works in your favor. If you have carrier insurance that covers 80% of a claim, Amex covers the remaining 20% (minus your $50 deductible). You're essentially double-protected.
AppleCare+ Breakdown (2025 Pricing)
What Is AppleCare+?
AppleCare+ is Apple's extended warranty and insurance program that extends your device's coverage beyond the standard 1-year limited warranty.
For iPhone 16 Pro/Pro Max:
- Cost: $13.49/month ($161.88 annually) or $269 for 2 years upfront
- Screen repair: $29 deductible
- Other damage: $99 deductible
- Theft/loss: $149 deductible
- Claims: Unlimited repairs (but only 2 theft/loss claims per year)
For iPhone 16/16 Plus:
- Cost: $10.49/month ($125.88 annually) or $219 for 2 years upfront
- Same deductibles as Pro models
For older iPhones (14, 15 series):
- Cost: $11.49-$12.49/month depending on model
- Same deductibles
What AppleCare+ Covers
Hardware defects and failures: If your iPhone stops working due to a manufacturing defect—even after the 1-year warranty expires—AppleCare+ covers the repair at no cost.
Battery replacement: If your battery capacity drops below 80%, Apple replaces it for free (without AppleCare+, this costs $89-$99).
Unlimited accidental damage: You can have your iPhone repaired as many times as needed during your coverage period. Each incident requires a deductible ($29 for screens, $99 for other damage).
Theft and loss protection: Up to two incidents per 12-month period with a $149 deductible per incident. This effectively gives you a replacement iPhone for $149 instead of $1,000+.
Priority technical support: 24/7 access to Apple specialists via chat or phone.
Express replacement: Apple ships you a replacement device before you return the damaged one, minimizing downtime.
The Real Cost of AppleCare+
Let's calculate the actual expense over 2 years for an iPhone 16 Pro:
Monthly subscription path:
- $13.49 × 24 months = $323.76
Plus one screen repair:
- $323.76 + $29 deductible = $352.76 total
Without AppleCare+:
- One screen repair = $379
Savings with AppleCare+: $26.24 (minimal)
The break-even point: You need at least 2 incidents within 2 years for AppleCare+ to provide meaningful savings over out-of-pocket repairs—assuming those incidents are only screen damage. If you have other types of damage ($99 deductible), AppleCare+ becomes worthwhile with just 1.5 incidents.
Head-to-Head Comparison
Coverage Limits
Amex Cell Phone Protection:
- $800 per claim
- $1,600 per 12-month period
- Two claims maximum per year
AppleCare+:
- Unlimited repairs for accidental damage
- Two theft/loss claims per year
- No per-incident dollar cap
Winner: AppleCare+ for comprehensive coverage, Amex for high-value single incidents
Deductibles
Amex:
- Flat $50 deductible for any claim type
AppleCare+:
- $29 for screen damage
- $99 for other accidental damage
- $149 for theft/loss
Winner: AppleCare+ for screen-only damage, Amex for other damage types and theft
Cost Analysis
Amex:
- $0 additional cost (included with eligible cards that have annual fees ranging from $0-$895)
- For Platinum Card holders: $895 annual fee includes cell phone protection + dozens of other benefits
AppleCare+:
- $126-$162 annually depending on iPhone model
- This is a standalone cost with no other benefits
Winner: Amex (free benefit vs. $140+ annual expense)
What's Actually Covered
Real-World Scenarios
Scenario 1: Cracked screen
- Amex: $50 deductible, reimbursed for repair costs
- AppleCare+: $29 deductible + already paid $162 this year = $191 total
- Amex saves: $141
Scenario 2: Stolen iPhone
- Amex: $50 deductible, up to $800 reimbursement (covers most iPhones except Pro Max)
- AppleCare+: $149 deductible + $162 annual cost = $311 total
- Amex saves: $261
Scenario 3: Battery replacement (18 months in)
- Amex: Not covered (pay $89-$99 out of pocket)
- AppleCare+: Free if capacity below 80%
- AppleCare+ saves: $89
Scenario 4: Two repairs in one year
- Amex: $50 × 2 = $100 in deductibles
- AppleCare+: $29 + $99 = $128 in deductibles + $162 annual cost = $290
- Amex saves: $190
Which Amex Cards Offer Cell Phone Protection
Tier 1: Premium Personal Cards
American Express Platinum Card® (See Rates & Fees)
Coverage details:
- Up to $800 per claim, $1,600 per year
- $50 deductible per claim
- Two claims per 12-month period
- Covers screen damage, theft, accidental damage
Why this matters: The Platinum Card's $895 annual fee includes cell phone protection plus:
- Up to $600 annual hotel credit
- Up to $200 Uber Cash + $120 Uber One credit
- Up to $400 Resy dining credit
- Up to $300 digital entertainment credit
- Up to Global airport lounge access
- Total benefits value: $2,419+
Terms apply to American Express benefits and offers. Enrollment may be required for select American Express benefits and offers. Visit americanexpress.com to learn more. Eligibility and Benefit level varies by Card. Terms, Conditions, and Limitations Apply. Please visit americanexpress.com/benefitsguide for more details. Underwritten by Amex Assurance Company.
The value proposition: You're essentially getting free cell phone protection as part of a comprehensive benefits package.
[[ SINGLE_CARD * {"id": "106", "isExpanded": "false", "bestForCategoryId": "15", "bestForText": "Frequent Travelers", "headerHint": "Serious Points on Flights"} ]]
Tier 2: Business Cards
The Business Platinum Card® from American Express (See Rates & Fees)
Same coverage as personal Platinum:
- $800 per claim, $1,600 annually
- $50 deductible
- Two claims per year
Additional business benefits:
- 5X on flights and prepaid hotels (up to $500K annually)
- 1.5X points on purchases over $5,000 (up to $2M annually)
- Same $895 annual fee with business-focused credits
[[ SINGLE_CARD * {"id": "2290", "isExpanded": "true", "bestForCategoryId": "52", "bestForText": "Business Owners", "headerHint" : "Premium Offer" } ]]
Tier 3: Co-Branded Amex Cards
Delta SkyMiles® Reserve American Express Card (See Rates & Fees)
Cell phone protection:
- Same $800/$1,600 coverage
- $50 deductible
- Two claims annually
Why choose this: If you fly Delta frequently, this card combines:
- Cell phone protection
- First checked bag free (saves $30-35 per flight)
- Priority boarding
- Delta Sky Club access
- Lower $550 annual fee than Platinum
[[ SINGLE_CARD * {"id": "781", "isExpanded": "false", "bestForCategoryId": "15", "bestForText": "Frequent Travelers", "headerHint": "Most Premium Delta Offer"} ]]
When to Choose Amex Over AppleCare+
Scenario 1: You Have an Expensive Amex Card Already
If you already pay: $325-$895 for an Amex card with this benefit, you're getting cell phone protection "free" as part of your existing investment.
Why double-pay? Adding AppleCare+ costs another $140-$162 annually. That's up to $1,057 total for phone protection plus card benefits—likely unnecessary.
Best strategy: Use Amex as your primary protection. Skip AppleCare+ unless you lose phones frequently (Amex doesn't cover loss, only theft).
Scenario 2: You're a Careful Phone User
The statistics: If you've never cracked a screen or damaged a phone in 5+ years of ownership, insurance is a poor investment.
The math: Over 2 years, you'll pay $324-$647 for AppleCare+ (depending on model and subscription vs. upfront). If you have zero claims, that's $324-$647 lost.
Amex advantage: Since the protection is free with your existing card, there's no wasted money if you never file a claim.
Scenario 3: Family with Multiple Phones
The multiplier effect: A family of four with iPhone 16 models would pay:
- AppleCare+: $10.49 × 4 = $41.96/month ($503.52/year)
- Amex: $0 additional (all four lines covered under one monthly bill payment)
Annual savings: $503.52 by using Amex instead of AppleCare+
Scenario 4: You Want Maximum Claims Per Year
Amex: Two claims per year, $50 each = $100 total in deductibles
AppleCare+: Unlimited repair claims = potentially lower overall cost if you damage phones frequently
The break-even: If you have 3+ incidents per year, AppleCare+ becomes more cost-effective due to unlimited repairs. But if you're damaging your phone 3+ times annually, consider a better case or screen protector.
When AppleCare+ Is Worth The Extra Cost
Reason 1: You Lose Phones (Not Just Damage)
The gap: Amex covers theft but NOT loss. If you have a history of misplacing phones, AppleCare+'s loss coverage ($149 deductible) is valuable.
Real scenario: You leave your iPhone at a restaurant. It's gone. With AppleCare+, you pay $149 for a replacement. Without it, you're paying $1,000+ for a new device.
Reason 2: You Want Battery Protection
Battery degradation is real: After 500 charge cycles (roughly 18-24 months for heavy users), iPhone batteries often drop below 80% capacity.
Replacement costs:
- Without AppleCare+: $89-$99
- With AppleCare+: Free
Who benefits: Heavy users who keep phones 3+ years. By year 2-3, battery replacement alone justifies AppleCare+'s cost.
Reason 3: You Have AppleCare One (Multiple Devices)
Apple's new offering: AppleCare One covers multiple devices (iPhone, iPad, Apple Watch, Mac) for $19.99/month (up to 3 devices).
The calculation:
- iPhone 16 Pro AppleCare+ alone: $13.49/month
- Add an iPad ($4.99/month): Total would be $18.48
- AppleCare One for both: $19.99
When it makes sense: If you're protecting 2-3 Apple devices, AppleCare One provides better value than individual plans and can work alongside Amex protection for layered coverage.
Reason 4: You Want Priority Support and Express Replacement
AppleCare+ includes:
- 24/7 priority technical support
- Express replacement (receive new device before sending back damaged one)
- Genius Bar priority appointments
Amex provides: Claim reimbursement only—you handle all repairs/replacements yourself
Who benefits: Users who value convenience and quick device swaps over maximizing savings.
Reason 5: You're Accident-Prone
The frequency test: If you've cracked 3+ screens in the past 2 years, you're a high-claims user.
AppleCare+ advantage: Unlimited repairs mean no annual claim limits. You can break your phone 10 times and still get it fixed (though at $29-$99 each time).
Amex limitation: Two claims per year maximum. If you exceed this, you're paying full repair costs for additional incidents.
The Hybrid Strategy (Best of Both Worlds)
Stacking Amex + AppleCare+ for Maximum Protection
While it might seem redundant, some users benefit from having both protections:
Primary coverage: AppleCare+
- Handles most repairs with low deductibles ($29 screens)
- Provides express replacement
- Covers loss (not just theft)
Secondary coverage: Amex
- Reimburses your AppleCare+ deductibles
- Provides additional $800 per claim if AppleCare+ is maxed out
- Acts as backup for theft claims (lower $50 deductible vs. $149)
How it works in practice:
Incident 1 (Cracked screen):
- File AppleCare+ claim: Pay $29 deductible
- File Amex claim: Get reimbursed for $29 (minus Amex's $50 deductible = you pay $21 net)
- Total out-of-pocket: $21 instead of $29
Wait, that's more expensive! Actually, Amex works better as secondary for higher-deductible incidents:
Incident 2 (Water damage):
- File AppleCare+ claim: Pay $99 deductible
- File Amex claim: Amex covers $49 of the deductible (you still pay their $50 deductible)
- Total out-of-pocket: $50 instead of $99
Who Should Consider The Hybrid Approach
High-value device users: If you have iPhone 16 Pro Max ($1,199), stacking protection makes sense—the device replacement cost justifies double coverage.
Frequent travelers: Higher risk of theft/loss/damage. Having both protections means you're covered in more scenarios with lower out-of-pocket costs.
Business owners: Using a Business Platinum Card (cell phone protection) while maintaining AppleCare+ for business phones provides both personal and corporate-level coverage.
Risk-averse individuals: If $149-$379 in potential repair costs would strain your budget, paying $162/year for AppleCare+ plus having Amex backup offers peace of mind.
How to File an Amex Cell Phone Protection Claim
Step 1: Document the Incident
For theft: File a police report within 48 hours. You'll need the report number for your claim.
For damage: Take photos of the damaged device showing the extent of damage.
For all claims: Save receipts for any repairs you've already paid for.
Step 2: Start Your Claim Online
Visit americanexpress.com and navigate to Benefits > Cell Phone Protection > File a Claim
Or call the number on the back of your card and request cell phone protection claims assistance.
Step 3: Submit Required Documentation
You'll need:
- Your monthly cell phone bill showing the damaged/stolen device's line
- Proof you paid the bill with your eligible Amex card
- Police report (for theft claims)
- Repair invoice or replacement receipt
- Photos of damage
Processing time: Claims typically process within 7-14 business days once all documentation is received.
Step 4: Receive Reimbursement
Payment methods:
- Direct deposit to your bank account
- Mailed check
Deductible: $50 is automatically deducted from your reimbursement amount.
Common Claim Mistakes to Avoid
Mistake #1: Not paying with the right card
The problem: You have an Amex Platinum but pay your phone bill with a Chase Sapphire card. Your Amex protection doesn't activate.
The fix: Set up automatic payments using your eligible Amex card.
Mistake #2: Waiting too long to file
The problem: Damage occurred 90 days ago, you file today, and the claim is denied due to timing requirements.
The fix: File claims within 30 days of the incident whenever possible.
Mistake #3: Incomplete documentation
The problem: You submit your claim without the police report (for theft) or repair receipt, causing delays.
The fix: Gather all documents before starting the claim process.
Bottom Line - Which Protection Makes Sense For You?
Choose Amex Cell Phone Protection Alone If:
✅ You already have an eligible Amex card (Platinum, Business Platinum, or Delta Reserve)
✅ You're a careful phone user with few damage incidents
✅ You don't lose phones (Amex covers theft but not loss)
✅ You have a family plan (all lines covered under one bill)
✅ You want to avoid paying $140-$162/year for AppleCare+
✅ You're comfortable handling repairs yourself and waiting for reimbursement
Real profile: Marcus has had the Platinum Card® from American Express for 3 years. He flies frequently (utilizing the card's airport lounge access) and already uses the $600 hotel credit. Adding AppleCare+ would cost $162/year—an expense he avoids by using his built-in Amex cell phone protection. In 3 years, he's filed one claim (cracked screen, $50 deductible) and saved $486 compared to paying for AppleCare+.
Choose AppleCare+ If:
✅ You lose phones frequently (not just damage them)
✅ You're keeping your device 3+ years and want battery replacement coverage
✅ You value priority support and express replacement convenience
✅ You damage phones 3+ times per year (unlimited repairs with AppleCare+)
✅ You don't have an Amex card with cell phone protection
✅ You want protection for manufacturing defects beyond the 1-year warranty
✅ You have multiple Apple devices and can bundle with AppleCare One
Real profile: Jessica drops her phone often—she's had 4 screen repairs in 2 years. AppleCare+'s unlimited repair coverage makes sense for her: she pays $162/year + $29 per repair = $278 total for 4 repairs. Without it, she'd pay $1,516 in out-of-pocket screen repairs. Even with Amex protection (2 claims max), she'd exceed the annual limit.
Consider Both (Hybrid Strategy) If:
✅ You have a high-value device ($1,000+)
✅ You travel frequently for work (higher risk of loss/theft/damage)
✅ Budget isn't a primary concern—peace of mind is
✅ You want the lowest possible out-of-pocket costs per incident
✅ You're a business owner protecting company devices
The Verdict: Smart Money Says Use Amex First
For most iPhone owners who already have an eligible Amex card, AppleCare+ is an unnecessary expense. The Amex benefit provides robust coverage—$800 per claim, $50 deductible—at no additional cost.
The three-step decision framework:
Step 1: Check if you have an eligible Amex card with cell phone protection
Step 2: Assess your risk profile:
- Low risk (0-1 incidents per 2 years): Amex alone is sufficient
- Medium risk (2 incidents per 2 years): Amex saves money over AppleCare+
- High risk (3+ incidents per 2 years OR history of losing phones): Add AppleCare+
Step 3: Set up automatic cell phone bill payments with your Amex card
Follow this framework, and you'll protect your $1,000+ iPhone while avoiding $140-$162 in annual AppleCare+ costs—savings that compound to $280-$324 over a typical 2-year device ownership period.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Amex cell phone protection cover screen damage specifically?
Yes. Amex is one of the few credit card issuers that explicitly covers screen damage, which is the most common type of phone damage. You'll pay a $50 deductible and can claim up to $800 in repair/replacement costs.
Do I need to enroll in Amex cell phone protection?
No. The protection automatically activates when you pay your monthly cell phone bill with an eligible Amex card. There's no separate enrollment process.
Will Amex cover my entire family's phones?
Yes. All phone lines listed on your monthly cell phone bill are covered, as long as you pay the entire bill with your eligible Amex card.
Can I have both Amex protection and AppleCare+?
Yes. Amex cell phone protection is "secondary coverage," meaning if you have AppleCare+, it pays first. Amex can then reimburse remaining costs (like AppleCare+ deductibles) minus Amex's $50 deductible.
What if my phone costs more than $800?
Amex covers up to $800 per claim. If your iPhone 16 Pro Max costs $1,199 to replace, Amex pays $800 and you're responsible for the remaining $399 (plus your $50 deductible). AppleCare+ covers full replacement for $149 deductible, making it better for the highest-end devices.
Does Amex cover lost phones?
No. Amex covers theft (when stolen) and accidental damage, but not lost phones. If you frequently misplace devices, AppleCare+'s loss coverage ($149 deductible) is valuable.
How long does an Amex claim take to process?
Claims typically take 7-14 business days once all required documentation is submitted. You'll receive reimbursement via direct deposit or mailed check.
Can I use Amex protection if I bought my phone from my carrier?
Yes. The benefit covers any phone on your monthly bill, regardless of where you purchased it—Apple Store, carrier store, or third-party retailer.
Do I have to get my phone repaired at Apple to use Amex protection?
No. You can use any repair provider. Amex reimburses you for covered repair/replacement costs up to $800 per claim, regardless of who performs the service.
Is AppleCare+ still worth it if I have Amex protection?
For most users, no. Amex provides sufficient coverage at no additional cost. AppleCare+ makes sense only if you: (1) lose phones frequently, (2) want battery replacement coverage, or (3) damage phones 3+ times per year.
Maximize Your Card Benefits with Kudos
Your Amex card offers cell phone protection—but that's just one of dozens of benefits you might not be using. The average cardholder leaves $624 in card benefits unused every year simply because they forget what their cards offer.
Kudos solves this problem. Kudos is a free browser extension that tracks all your credit card benefits automatically and reminds you when it's time to use them—so you never waste another perk.
What Kudos does:
✅ Tracks cell phone protection eligibility across all your cards
✅ Reminds you when annual credits are about to expire
✅ Automatically recommends the best card for every purchase
✅ Finds hidden benefits you didn't know existed
Real impact: Kudos users with 2-3 premium cards save an average of $441 annually by optimizing their card usage. That's enough to cover AppleCare+ for three phones—or better yet, skip AppleCare+ entirely and pocket the savings.
Special offer: Get $20 back on your first eligible purchase when you sign up for Kudos using code "GET20."
Unlock your extra benefits when you become a Kudos member
Turn your online shopping into even more rewards
Join over 400,000 members simplifying their finances
Editorial Disclosure: Opinions expressed here are those of Kudos alone, not those of any bank, credit card issuer, hotel, airline, or other entity. This content has not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any of the entities included within the post.
.webp)
.webp)
.webp)
