Kudos has partnered with CardRatings and Red Ventures for our coverage of credit card products. Kudos, CardRatings, and Red Ventures may receive a commission from card issuers. Kudos may receive commission from card issuers. Some of the card offers that appear on Kudos are from advertisers and may impact how and where card products appear on the site. Kudos tries to include as many card companies and offers as we are aware of, including offers from issuers that don't pay us, but we may not cover all card companies or all available card offers. You don't have to use our links, but we're grateful when you do!
Downgrading Credit Cards: How to Keep Your Credit History Without the Annual Fee
July 1, 2025
.webp)
That premium credit card with the hefty annual fee seemed like a great idea when you signed up. The airport lounge access, statement credits, and exclusive perks justified the $695 price tag—until they didn't.
Maybe you're traveling less. Perhaps your spending habits have shifted. Or maybe you're simply not using those benefits enough to justify the cost. Whatever the reason, you're staring at another annual fee charge and wondering: "Is there a way out of this without hurting my credit?"
The answer is yes—and it's called downgrading.
What Credit Card Downgrading Actually Means
Credit card downgrading (also called a "product change") means switching your current card to a different card from the same issuer—typically one with a lower annual fee or no fee at all.
Here's what makes it different from canceling your card: Your account stays open. You keep the same account number, credit history, and credit limit. The issuer simply converts your existing account to a different card product.
The result? You eliminate or reduce the annual fee while protecting two crucial factors that impact your credit score: your length of credit history and your total available credit.
Why Downgrading Beats Canceling Every Time
When you cancel a credit card, three negative things happen to your credit profile:
1. Your Available Credit Drops
Closing a card immediately reduces your total available credit. If you carry balances on other cards, your credit utilization ratio—the percentage of available credit you're using—increases.
The numbers: Let's say you have three credit cards with $10,000 limits each ($30,000 total) and you're carrying $6,000 in balances across all cards. Your utilization is 20%.
Cancel one card, and your available credit drops to $20,000. Now your $6,000 in balances represents 30% utilization—pushing you above the recommended 30% threshold that credit scoring models prefer.
2. Your Credit History Takes a Hit
The age of your credit accounts makes up 15% of your FICO score. While closed accounts remain on your credit report for up to 10 years, they eventually disappear—taking years of positive credit history with them.
If the card you're canceling is one of your oldest accounts, you're essentially erasing your longest credit relationship.
3. You Lose the Account Permanently
Once you cancel, that's it. If you want a card from that issuer again, you'll need to apply from scratch—triggering a hard inquiry and potentially facing restrictions on welcome bonus eligibility.
When you downgrade instead:
- Your account stays open and continues aging
- Your available credit remains unchanged
- No hard inquiry hits your credit report
- Your credit score stays protected
When You Should Consider Downgrading
Not every situation calls for a downgrade, but these scenarios make it the smart move:
The Annual Fee Exceeds Your Value
This is the most common reason. You signed up for premium perks, but your lifestyle changed. Calculate the math, if the numbers don't add up, it's time to downgrade.
The Card is One of Your Oldest Accounts
If this card represents significant credit history—especially if it's your oldest card—downgrading preserves that valuable account age. Closing it would eventually shorten your credit history and potentially lower your credit score.
You Want to Maintain the Credit Limit
A $20,000 credit limit on a premium card helps your overall credit utilization, even if you're not actively using the card. Downgrading keeps that credit line available.
You're Under Issuer Application Restrictions
Chase's 5/24 rule? American Express's 2/90 limit? If you're already near these thresholds, downgrading allows you to keep an account open without burning a new application slot.
How to Downgrade Your Credit Card: Step-by-Step
The downgrade process is surprisingly simple, but following these steps ensures the smoothest experience:
Step 1: Research Your Downgrade Options
Before calling, know which cards you can downgrade to. Most issuers only allow downgrades within the same card "family."
Check the issuer's website or call to confirm available options for your specific card.
Step 2: Calculate Your Value First
Use Kudos Insights to see if you're actually maximizing your current card's benefits. According to research, the average cardholder leaves $624 in card benefits unused each year—maybe you're leaving value on the table without realizing it.
Kudos Insights automatically identifies missed perks and credits, helping you make an informed decision about whether to keep or downgrade your card.
Step 3: Redeem Any Outstanding Rewards
Some card downgrades allow your rewards to transfer seamlessly, especially within the same rewards ecosystem. But it's safer to redeem first.
Check these factors:
- Will your points transfer to the new card?
- Are you losing access to premium redemption options (like transferring to airline partners)?
- Do you have any pending statement credits that haven't posted yet?
Step 4: Call the Number on Your Card
Most issuers require a phone call for downgrades—you typically can't do this online. Have your account information ready and be prepared to explain why you want to downgrade.
What to say: "I'd like to keep my account open, but the annual fee no longer makes sense for my spending. I'd like to downgrade to [specific card name]. Can you help me with that?"
Step 5: Listen for Retention Offers
Here's where it gets interesting: When you request a downgrade, the representative might offer you a retention bonus to keep your current card.
Common retention offers include:
- Annual fee waiver for one year
- Bonus points (10,000-30,000 points)
- Statement credits ($100-$300)
Run the math: If they offer you 30,000 points worth $300, does that make the annual fee worth it for another year? If yes, accept the retention offer. If not, proceed with the downgrade.
Step 6: Confirm the Details
Before ending the call, verify:
- The name of your new card
- Any changes to your credit limit (there usually aren't any)
- When your new card will arrive (typically 7-10 business days)
- What happens to your rewards points
- Whether your account number remains the same (it usually does)
Step 7: Activate Your New Card
When your new card arrives, activate it immediately. Check your online account to ensure it now reflects the new card product. Your account history should remain completely intact—just under a new card name.
Issuer-Specific Downgrade Rules You Must Know
Each credit card issuer has different policies governing downgrades. Understanding these rules prevents surprises:
Chase: The One-Year Rule
Chase typically requires your account to be open for at least 12 months before approving a downgrade request. This prevents users from opening premium cards just for welcome bonuses, then immediately downgrading.
Pro tip: If you're planning to eventually upgrade back to a premium Chase card (to earn another welcome bonus), check Chase's bonus eligibility rules. You typically can't earn a new bonus on a card if you've had it open within the past 48 months.
American Express: Family Restrictions
American Express allows downgrades within card families, but co-branded cards (like airline or hotel cards) typically can't be downgraded to non-cobranded cards.
Capital One: More Flexible Options
Capital One reportedly offers more flexibility, sometimes allowing product changes between different card families. However, the one-card-every-six-months rule still applies to new applications.
What Happens to Your Rewards When You Downgrade
Rewards handling varies by issuer and card type:
Points That Transfer Seamlessly
If you're staying within the same rewards ecosystem, your points typically remain accessible.
Rewards You Might Lose
Co-branded card points: Downgrading an airline or hotel card might affect point transfers or redemption options, even if the points remain in your account.
Enhanced redemption values: If you earned points on a premium card that offered bonus redemption values (like 1.5 cents per point through Chase travel portal), downgrading might reduce future redemption value—though points you've already earned remain.
Best practice: Redeem valuable points before downgrading to avoid any complications.
Common Downgrade Mistakes to Avoid
Mistake #1: Downgrading Too Soon After Opening
Most issuers frown upon immediate downgrades. As mentioned, Chase requires 12 months. Opening a card, collecting the bonus, then immediately downgrading can result in bonus clawbacks or account restrictions.
Wait at least one year before requesting a downgrade.
Mistake #2: Not Exploring Retention Offers First
That retention offer might actually make your premium card worth keeping for another year. Always listen to what the representative offers before finalizing your downgrade decision.
Mistake #3: Forgetting About Authorized Users
If you have authorized users on your card, they'll need new cards too after the downgrade. Make sure everyone updates their card information for recurring payments.
Mistake #4: Downgrading Your Oldest Card Without Considering Alternatives
If the card you want to downgrade is your oldest account, and you have other cards with annual fees, consider whether those other cards might be better candidates for closing or downgrading.
Alternative Strategies: When NOT to Downgrade
Downgrading isn't always the best move. Consider these alternatives:
Keep the Card for One More Year
If you received a strong retention offer, keeping the card might provide more value than downgrading. Run the numbers carefully.
Upgrade Instead
Sometimes upgrading to a premium card makes more sense than downgrading. If your spending has increased or you're traveling more, that higher annual fee might now pay for itself.
Kudos Hidden Perks can help you identify whether you're maximizing premium card benefits before making the upgrade decision.
Cancel Strategically
If the card is relatively new (under 2 years old) and isn't one of your oldest accounts, canceling might be acceptable—especially if you want to apply for the same card again in the future to earn another welcome bonus.
How Downgrading Affects Different Credit Card Types
Premium Travel Cards
These cards offer the most obvious downgrade opportunities. If you're not using lounge access, statement credits, or travel protections, downgrading to a no-fee card preserves your account while eliminating unnecessary costs.
Cash Back Cards
Cash back cards rarely have high annual fees to begin with, making downgrades less common. However, if you have a card with a modest annual fee and you're not maximizing bonus categories, switching to a flat-rate no-fee card might make sense.
Business Credit Cards
Business card downgrades follow similar rules, but they offer one advantage: most business cards don't count toward Chase's 5/24 rule. This means you can sometimes downgrade business cards more freely without impacting personal card application strategies.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does downgrading hurt your credit score?
No. Downgrading preserves your account history and available credit, so it shouldn't negatively impact your credit score. Unlike opening a new card, downgrades typically don't trigger hard inquiries.
Can I upgrade back to my original card later?
Usually yes, but policies vary by issuer. Some issuers allow upgrades after a certain waiting period. However, upgrading back to your original card likely won't make you eligible for a new welcome bonus.
How long does the downgrade process take?
The phone call typically takes 10-15 minutes, and your new card usually arrives within 7-10 business days. Your account updates immediately in most cases.
Will I get a refund on my annual fee?
If you request a downgrade within 30-60 days of your annual fee posting, many issuers will refund a prorated portion of the fee. Policies vary, so ask when you call.
Can I downgrade a card with a balance?
Yes. Your balance transfers to the new card, and your payment terms typically remain the same. However, if you're currently taking advantage of a promotional APR, confirm that it will continue after the downgrade.
What if the issuer denies my downgrade request?
Denial is rare, but it happens. If denied, ask why and whether there are alternative downgrade options. If you've had the account less than a year, waiting might resolve the issue.
The Bottom Line
Downgrading a credit card is one of the smartest moves you can make when an annual fee no longer justifies its cost. By converting your card to a no-fee or lower-fee option, you eliminate the expense while protecting your credit history and available credit—two factors that significantly impact your credit score.
The process is straightforward: research your options, calculate the value you're actually getting, call your card issuer, and listen for potential retention offers. Most importantly, wait at least 12 months after opening a card before requesting a downgrade.
Remember: Credit cards should work for you, not against you. If you're paying for perks you don't use, downgrading puts you back in control of your finances without sacrificing your credit score.
Ready to optimize your entire card portfolio? Use Kudos Explore Cards to discover which cards align best with your current spending patterns—ensuring every card in your wallet earns its place.
Unlock your extra benefits when you become a Kudos member
Turn your online shopping into even more rewards
Join over 400,000 members simplifying their finances
Editorial Disclosure: Opinions expressed here are those of Kudos alone, not those of any bank, credit card issuer, hotel, airline, or other entity. This content has not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any of the entities included within the post.
.webp)
.webp)
.webp)
