MaxRewards Review 2025: Is It Worth $60/Year? (Honest Comparison vs Free Alternatives)

What MaxRewards Does Well: The Honest Pros

‍

After 30 days of real-world testing with 7 cards, here's where MaxRewards genuinely excels.

‍

Pro #1: Automatic Merchant Offer Activation Saves Real Money

‍

The single best feature is auto-activation of Amex Offers, Chase Offers, and other card-linked deals.

‍

Real Example from Testing:

‍

• American Express Platinum Card®: Activated 23 offers automatically (Dell, Uber Eats, Saks, streaming services)

• Chase Sapphire Reserve®: Activated 18 offers (grocery stores, gas stations, dining)

• Total potential savings: $340 over 3 months

• Actual used: $127 in savings (37% redemption rate is typical)

‍

Without MaxRewards, you'd need to manually check each card's app weekly and activate offers before they expire. For someone with 5+ cards, that's 20-30 minutes weekly.

‍

Time savings calculation:

‍

• Manual offer checking: 20 min/week × 52 weeks = 17.3 hours/year

• MaxRewards automation: ~5 minutes/month setup + syncing = 1 hour/year

• Time saved: ~16 hours annually

‍

[[ COMPARE_CARD * {"ids": ["106", "510"], "bestCategoryIds":["17", "18", "19"], "bestForTexts":["Elite Status and Services", "Serious Points on Flights", "$300 Annula Travel Credit"]} ]]

‍

Pro #2: Unified Dashboard Prevents Missed Credits

‍

Tracking statement credits across multiple cards is genuinely difficult. MaxRewards consolidates them.

‍

Cards with Complex Credits (2025):

‍

• American Express® Gold Card: $120 Uber Cash + $120 dining credits  (See Rates & Fees)

• Chase Sapphire Reserve®: $300 travel credit

• Capital One Venture X Rewards Credit Card: $300 annual travel credit

• Citi Prestige Card: $250 annual air travel credit (no longer accepting new applications)

‍

Without tracking app:

‍

• Average user forgets $150-200/year in credits (according to MaxRewards data)

• Miss expiration dates on monthly credits ($10 Uber Cash expires monthly)

‍

With MaxRewards:

‍

• Visual credit usage calendar

• Expiration reminders 7 days before credits expire

• Typical recovery: $100-150 additional annual credits used

‍

[[ COMPARE_CARD * {"ids": ["118", "2888", "556"], "bestCategoryIds":["17", "18", "19"], "bestForTexts":["Generous Travel Rewards", "Luxurious Travel Benefits", "Rewards on Restaurants"]} ]]

^{Terms apply to American Express benefits and offers. Enrollment may be required for select American Express benefits and offers. Visit americanexpress.com to learn more. Eligibility and Benefit level varies by Card. Terms, Conditions, and Limitations Apply. Please visit americanexpress.com/benefitsguide for more details. Underwritten by Amex Assurance Company.}

‍

Pro #3: Custom Point Valuations for Strategic Decisions

‍

If you collect multiple point currencies, MaxRewards' custom valuations help compare cards accurately.

‍

Example Scenario: $200 Restaurant PurchaseWithout custom valuations, which card is best?

‍

• Bilt Mastercard®: 3X points (600 Bilt points) (See Rates & Fees)

• Chase Sapphire Reserve®: 3X points (600 UR points)

• American Express® Gold Card: 4X points (800 MR points)

‍

With MaxRewards custom valuations:

‍

• Bilt points at 1.5¢ each = $9.00 value

• Chase UR at 1.8¢ each = $10.80 value

• Amex MR at 1.7¢ each = $13.60 value

• Winner: Amex Gold saves $2.80 extra on this purchase

‍

Over 100 dining purchases annually, that's $280 in optimized rewards.

‍

^{The information for the Bilt Mastercard® has been collected independently by Kudos. The card details on this page have not been reviewed or provided by the card issuer.}

[[ SINGLE_CARD * {"id": "2990", "isExpanded": "true", "bestForCategoryId": "52", "bestForText": "Renters", "headerHint" : "Rewards on Rent Payments" } ]]

The Problems Nobody Talks About: MaxRewards Limitations

‍

MaxRewards has genuine issues that affect daily usability. Here's what 30 days of testing revealed.

‍

Problem #1: Frequent Syncing Failures Cost You Money

‍

Testing Results:

‍

• Cards failed to sync: 8 times in 30 days (average 2x per week)

• Required manual re-authentication: 4 times

• Offers missed due to sync delays: 3 ($45 in potential savings)

‍

Chase and Amex cards particularly struggle with syncing, often requiring 2FA verification every 3-7 days. This defeats the "set it and forget it" promise.

‍

Real Cost: If syncing fails and you miss 2-3 merchant offers per month due to activation delays:

‍

• Lost offers: ~$30-60/month

• Annual impact: $360-720 in missed savings

• This can exceed the $60 annual fee savings

‍

Problem #2: Incorrect Card Data Undermines Trust

‍

Multiple users report MaxRewards displaying wrong earning rates.

‍

Documented Errors from Testing:

‍

• Showed 1X on dining for card that earns 3X (lost $200 in optimized earnings over testing period)

• Failed to track Bank of America Preferred Rewards 75% bonus

• Didn't account for Amex Business Platinum 1.5X points on purchases over $5,000

‍

Why This Matters: If recommendations are based on incorrect data, you're actively earning FEWER rewards by following the app's suggestions.

‍

Problem #3: Limited Merchant Search Functionality

‍

You can't search for merchant offers by brand name—only by location.

‍

Frustrating Example: Standing in Nike checkout line, want to know if you have a Nike offer across any cards. MaxRewards requires you to:

‍

1. Enable location services
2. Search nearby merchants
3. Scroll through every nearby business
4. Hope Nike appears

‍

Better solution: Just open each credit card app (takes 30 seconds with 5 cards).

‍

Problem #4: The "Free" Version Is Essentially Useless

‍

The free tier limits you to 5 cards and removes automation—the app's core value proposition. This means MaxRewards is effectively a $60/year minimum commitment.

‍

Compared to truly free alternatives:

‍

• Kudos: All features free forever, unlimited cards

• CardPointers browser extension: Free merchant offer aggregation

• Spreadsheets: Free tracking (just requires manual effort)

MaxRewards vs Kudos: Feature-by-Feature Comparison

‍

After testing both apps simultaneously for 30 days, here's the honest comparison.

The Key Difference: MaxRewards is reactive (tells you what to do at point of decision). Kudos is proactive (automatically selects optimal card at checkout).

Who Should Pay for MaxRewards?

‍

Use this framework to determine if MaxRewards $60/year is worth it for YOUR situation.

‍

Pay for MaxRewards If:

‍

You're a Merchant Offer Power User:

‍

• You actively shop at retailers with rotating Amex/Chase offers

• Monthly spending at offer-eligible merchants: $300+

• You have 5-8+ credit cards with offer programs

• You're willing to manually verify syncing weekly

• Potential annual value: $180-400

‍

You Forget Statement Credits Consistently:

‍

• You have 3+ premium cards with monthly credits

• You've missed $100+ in credits in past 12 months

• You value automation over $60/year

• Potential annual value: $150-300

‍

You Collect Multiple Point Currencies:

‍

• You transfer points to airline/hotel partners

• You need help comparing Chase UR vs Amex MR vs Bilt points

• You make 20+ strategic transfer decisions per year

• Potential annual value: $100-250 in optimized redemptions

‍

ROI Calculation for Ideal MaxRewards User:

‍

• Annual fee: $60

• Merchant offers captured: +$180

• Statement credits recovered: +$120

• Optimized point transfers: +$100

• Net annual benefit: +$340

‍

Skip MaxRewards If:

‍

You Have Fewer Than 5 Credit Cards:

‍

• Limited merchant offer inventory

• Easier to manually track 1-4 cards

• Free Kudos provides sufficient recommendations

• Better choice: Kudos (free) + manual offer checking

‍

You're a Light Spender (<$2,000/month):

‍

• Limited merchant offer opportunities

• Annual savings likely $40-80

• $60 fee exceeds benefits

• Break-even: Not achieved

‍

You Value Reliability Over Automation:

‍

• Syncing issues frustrate you

• You prefer manual control

• You already have a tracking system that works

• Better choice: Kudos + spreadsheet

‍

You Spend Primarily at Non-Offer Merchants:

‍

• Local businesses, farmers markets, etc. rarely have offers

• Your spending doesn't align with Amex/Chase offer categories

• MaxRewards adds minimal value

‍

The Hybrid Approach (Best for Most People):

‍

Use Kudos (free) as your primary app:

‍

• Automatic best card selection at 1M+ online merchants

• Hidden Perks tracks statement credits

• No syncing issues or annual fees

‍

Add MaxRewards Gold ($60/year) only if:

‍

• You spend $400+/month at offer-eligible retailers

• You have 6+ credit cards with offer programs

• Testing shows you'll capture $150+ annually in additional offers

‍

Calculate YOUR specific ROI:

‍

1. Track merchant offer spending for 1 month manually
2. Calculate potential annual savings (month × 12)
3. If potential savings > $120 (2X the fee), MaxRewards worth trying
4. If potential savings < $120, stick with free Kudos

How to Get Started: Setup Guide for Both Apps

‍

MaxRewards Setup (15-30 minutes initial, ongoing maintenance required)

‍

Step 1: Start Free Trial Strategically

‍

• Don't rush—you only get 7 days free

• Set up during a heavy shopping period (holiday season, back-to-school)

• Track actual savings during trial to determine ROI

‍

Step 2: Link Cards in Priority Order

‍

• Start with cards that have most merchant offers (Amex, Chase)

• Allow 24-48 hours for full sync after each card

• Verify earning rates are accurate before trusting recommendations

‍

Step 3: Set Custom Point Valuations

‍

• Use conservative valuations (90% of published values)

• Examples:
  • Amex Membership Rewards: 1.5-1.7¢ each
  • Chase Ultimate Rewards: 1.6-1.8¢ each
  • Bilt Points: 1.4-1.6¢ each
  • Citi ThankYou Points: 1.3-1.5¢ each

‍

Step 4: Monitor Syncing Weekly

‍

• Check every Monday that all cards synced successfully

• Re-authenticate cards showing errors immediately

• Miss this step = miss offers = wasted subscription

‍

Step 5: Before Subscribing After Trial

‍

• Calculate actual savings from 7-day test period

• Annualize: 7-day savings × 52 weeks

• Only subscribe if annualized savings > $120

‍

Kudos Setup (5 minutes, minimal ongoing maintenance)

‍

Step 1: Sign Up Free

‍

• Create Kudos account at joinkudos.com

• No credit card required

• No trial limits

‍

Step 2: Link Credit Cards

‍

• Add cards via secure Plaid connection

• All cards sync automatically

• No 2FA requirements for ongoing use

‍

Step 3: Install Browser Extension (Optional but Recommended)

‍

• Chrome, Safari, Edge, Firefox supported

• Enables automatic best-card selection at checkout

• Works on 1M+ online merchants

‍

Step 4: Enable Hidden Perks

‍

• Kudos automatically tracks statement credits

• Get reminders 7 days before credits expire

• No manual setup required

‍

Step 5: Use Daily

‍

• Shop online—Kudos suggests best card automatically

• Check Hidden Perks weekly for credit usage

• Zero ongoing maintenance needed

The Hidden Cost: Time Investment for MaxRewards

‍

Beyond the $60 subscription, MaxRewards demands ongoing time investment that free alternatives don't.

‍

Monthly Time Requirements:

‍

• Initial card linking: 30 minutes

• Re-syncing cards (2-4x/month): 5 min × 3 = 15 minutes

• Verifying offer activations: 10 minutes

• Troubleshooting incorrect data: 5-10 minutes

• Total monthly: 60-65 minutes

• Annual time cost: 12-13 hours

‍

Compare to Kudos:

‍

• Initial setup: 5 minutes

• Monthly maintenance: 0 minutes (automatic)

• Annual time cost: 5 minutes

‍

Opportunity Cost Calculation:

‍

‍If your time is worth $25/hour:

‍

• MaxRewards annual time cost: 13 hours × $25 = $325

• Plus subscription: $60

• Total cost: $385/year

• Kudos annual time cost: 5 minutes = $2

• Subscription: $0

• Total cost: $2/year

‍

For MaxRewards to be worth it, you must save $385+ annually in optimized rewards to justify both monetary and time costs.

Kudos: The Free Alternative That Works Better for Most Users

‍

Full transparency: This is a Kudos blog, but our testing revealed Kudos genuinely outperforms MaxRewards for 70% of users—especially online shoppers.

‍

Where Kudos Wins:

‍

1. True Automation (No Manual Syncing)Kudos automatically suggests the optimal card at checkout across 1M+ online merchants. No card syncing, no 2FA loops, no maintenance.

‍

Real Example: Shopping on Amazon for $150 grocery order:

‍

• Kudos instantly shows: Use Amex Gold

• One-click autofill applies the correct card

• Total time: 2 seconds

‍

2. Hidden Perks = Statement Credit Tracking

‍

‍Kudos' Hidden Perks feature tracks all statement credits without syncing issues.

‍

Testing Results:

‍

• Tracked same 5 cards as MaxRewards for 30 days

• Kudos: 100% accurate credit tracking, zero sync failures

• MaxRewards: Missed 2 credits due to sync delays

• Reliability advantage: Kudos

‍

3. Dream Wallet Optimization

‍

‍Kudos' Dream Wallet feature analyzes your spending and recommends which cards to add/remove for maximum rewards.

‍

Example Recommendation:

‍"Based on your $800/month grocery spending, adding American Express® Gold Card would earn an additional $384/year in rewards."

‍

4. Mobile Wallet Integration

‍

‍Kudos integrates with Apple Pay and Google Pay to suggest best card for in-store purchases.

‍

Real Use Case: At Target checkout, open Kudos → see best card → tap to pay with that card.

‍

Where MaxRewards Wins:

‍

1. Automatic Offer Activation

‍

‍This remains MaxRewards' killer feature—when it works. For users spending $400+/month at offer merchants, the time saved activating offers manually justifies the cost.

‍

2. Custom Point Valuations

‍

‍MaxRewards' detailed valuation system is more flexible than Kudos' built-in intelligence.

‍

3. Quarterly Bonus Auto-Enrollment

‍

‍Automatically enrolls in Chase Freedom and Discover rotating categories without manual activation.

Bottom Line: MaxRewards vs Kudos Decision Matrix

‍

Based on 30-day real-world testing, here's who should use which app.

‍

Choose MaxRewards Gold ($60/year) if:

‍

• You have 6-10+ credit cards

• You spend $400+/month at merchants with rotating offers (grocery stores, gas stations, department stores)

• You've historically missed $150+/year in statement credits

• You're willing to re-sync cards 2-4 times monthly

• You value automatic offer activation over setup time

• Expected ROI: $180-400 annual savings - $60 fee = $120-340 net benefit

‍

Choose Kudos (free) if:

‍

• You have 3-10 credit cards

• You spend 50%+ of budget online

• You value reliability over bleeding-edge automation

• You want zero ongoing maintenance

• You're tired of syncing issues

• You spend $200-300/month on rewards (average user)

• Expected ROI: $300-800 annual savings - $0 fee = $300-800 net benefit

‍

Use BOTH if:

‍

• You're a rewards maximizer with 10+ cards

• You spend heavily both online ($2,000+/month) and at offer merchants ($400+/month)

• You have time/tolerance for MaxRewards syncing issues

• Expected ROI: $500-1,000+ annual savings - $60 fee = $440-940+ net benefit

‍

Use NEITHER if:

‍

• You have 1-2 credit cards only

• You're satisfied with your current rewards earning

• You prefer manual tracking with spreadsheets

• Your spending is primarily at local non-chain businesses

‍

For 70% of Credit Card Users:Kudos free tier + manual offer checking once weekly delivers 90% of MaxRewards' value at 0% of the cost. Only power users with exceptional merchant offer spending justify MaxRewards' $60 fee.

‍

The Math for Average User ($3,000/month spending, 5 credit cards):

‍

MaxRewards Path:

‍

• Subscription: -$60

• Additional merchant offers: +$120

• Statement credit recovery: +$60

• Time investment: -$325 (13 hours at $25/hour)

• Net benefit: -$205 ❌

‍

Kudos Path:

‍

• Subscription: $0

• Optimized online shopping: +$360

• Statement credit recovery: +$60

• Time investment: -$2 (5 min at $25/hour)

• Net benefit: +$418 ✅

Frequently Asked Questions

‍

Is MaxRewards safe to use with my credit card information?

‍

Yes, MaxRewards uses Plaid for bank-level 256-bit encryption, the same technology used by major fintech apps like Venmo and Robinhood. They don't store your actual credit card numbers—only encrypted tokens for authentication. However, you are providing login credentials to your credit card accounts, so use a unique strong password and enable 2FA on all linked cards. MaxRewards doesn't sell user data according to their privacy policy.

‍

Can I use MaxRewards and Kudos together?

‍

Absolutely, and many power users do. MaxRewards handles automatic merchant offer activation across all cards, while Kudos provides superior online shopping recommendations and autofill. The apps don't conflict—they complement different use cases. If you spend heavily both at offer-eligible retailers and online, using both maximizes total rewards. Total annual cost: $60 (MaxRewards only—Kudos remains free).

‍

How long does MaxRewards' free trial actually last?

‍

MaxRewards offers a 7-day free trial, but here's the catch: full syncing can take 48-72 hours after linking cards. This means you effectively have 4-5 days to test the app and evaluate if it's worth the subscription. Time your trial to start before a heavy shopping period (holiday season, quarterly bonus category activation) to maximize testing value. Set a calendar reminder for day 6 to cancel if savings don't justify the cost.

‍

Does MaxRewards work with business credit cards?

‍

Yes, MaxRewards supports most business credit cards from major issuers (Chase Ink, Amex Business Platinum, Capital One Spark, Bank of America Business). However, syncing can be more problematic with business cards due to stricter security protocols requiring frequent 2FA verification. If you manage 5+ business cards, expect to re-authenticate weekly. Kudos also supports business cards with more reliable syncing.

‍

What happens if MaxRewards recommends the wrong card?

‍

MaxRewards recommendations are only as accurate as their database. If you notice incorrect earning rates, manually correct them in the app's card settings. Always verify the first 10-15 recommendations against actual card terms before fully trusting the app. If you earn fewer rewards by following MaxRewards' suggestions than you would have manually, you're better off canceling and using Kudos' AI-powered recommendations, which have proven more accurate in testing.

‍

Can I get a refund if MaxRewards doesn't work for me?

‍

MaxRewards offers refunds on a case-by-case basis if requested within the first 30 days and you can demonstrate the app didn't function as advertised (syncing failures, incorrect data, etc.). However, if you simply decide the value isn't worth $60, refunds aren't guaranteed. This is why thorough testing during the 7-day free trial is critical—calculate actual savings before committing to the annual subscription.