Kudos has partnered with CardRatings and Red Ventures for our coverage of credit card products. Kudos, CardRatings, and Red Ventures may receive a commission from card issuers. Kudos may receive commission from card issuers. Some of the card offers that appear on Kudos are from advertisers and may impact how and where card products appear on the site. Kudos tries to include as many card companies and offers as we are aware of, including offers from issuers that don't pay us, but we may not cover all card companies or all available card offers. You don't have to use our links, but we're grateful when you do!
How to Choose the Best Pet Insurance Plan (2025 Beginner’s Guide)
December 12, 2024
Not sure which pet insurance to pick? This step-by-step guide will help you compare plans, understand key terms, and find the best pet insurance for your furry friend’s needs.
Choosing a pet insurance plan can feel overwhelming – deductibles, reimbursement rates, exclusions, oh my! Don’t worry. This guide is designed for beginners and will walk you through how to choose the best pet insurance step by step. By the end, you’ll know exactly what to look for (and what to avoid) to get a policy that fits your pet and your budget.
We’ll also answer common questions and give you tips to make the process easier. Let’s ensure your beloved pet gets the coverage they deserve, without overpaying or unwittingly missing something important.
1. Determine What You Want Covered
Start by identifying your priorities for coverage. Pet insurance plans vary – some are very broad, others are basic. Ask yourself:
- Do you want illness coverage, or just accident coverage? If you want coverage for sickness (e.g. ear infections, upset stomach, cancer), you need an Accident & Illness plan. If you only worry about major injuries (car accidents, broken bones), an Accident-Only plan could suffice (and be cheaper).
- What about routine care? Basic plans won’t cover routine vet visits, vaccines, dental cleanings, etc. If you want help with those costs, look for Wellness add-ons.
- Any specific concerns? Think about your pet’s breed or history. For example, if you have a breed prone to hip dysplasia or heart issues, ensure the policy doesn’t exclude those hereditary conditions.
By knowing what you must have, you can narrow down suitable plans quickly.
2. Set Your Budget (Premium & Potential Out-of-Pocket)
Pet insurance comes at various price points. It’s important to pick a plan you can afford both in monthly premiums and in the worst-case scenario out-of-pocket costs.
Here’s how to approach it:
- Get Sample Quotes: Use your pet’s details to fetch quotes from a few top insurers. This will give you a ballpark of monthly costs for different coverage levels.
- Decide on Deductible: A higher deductible means you’ll pay more out-of-pocket when something happens but less each month. If you want to keep premiums low, consider a $500 deductible plan. But ensure you could afford that $500 if an incident occurs. If not, a lower deductible (like $200) might be better even if monthly cost is higher.
- Choose Reimbursement Level: Most insurers let you pick: they’ll cover 70%, 80%, 90%, or even 100% of the vet bill after deductible. Higher reimbursement = higher premium. 80% is a popular middle ground.
- Check for Payment Caps: Some budget plans cap the maximum payout. Unlimited annual coverage is ideal but costs more. Think of a cap like your safety net limit. Big surgeries or cancer treatment can exceed that. Many mid-tier plans now offer $15,000 or unlimited annual limits; if within budget, leaning higher is safer.
A good approach is to choose the highest coverage you can comfortably afford on a monthly basis. It’s better to have a slightly less fancy plan that you won’t be tempted to cancel.
3. Compare Plans and Providers
Now comes the research part: comparing different insurance companies and their plans. Key factors to compare:
- Coverage Inclusions: Does the plan cover hereditary and congenital conditions? Chronic conditions for the life of the pet? Some top insurers cover these as standard, whereas a few cheaper ones might limit them. Look for phrasing like “no lifetime limits on per condition” etc.
- Exclusions & Fine Print: All plans have exclusions – the important part is knowing them. Common exclusions include pre-existing conditions, cosmetic procedures, breeding, etc. Some plans might uniquely exclude things like orthopedic conditions for the first 6 months. Read the sample policy if possible for any plan you’re serious about.
- Waiting Periods: Compare how long each makes you wait. A typical good policy: 14 days illness, 2-3 days accidents. If a policy has, say, 30 days for illnesses or special 6-month waits for cruciate ligament issues, note that. It’s not necessarily a deal-breaker, but shorter waiting periods = you can use coverage sooner.
- Age Limits: If your pet is a senior or approaching senior age, check the company’s age limits. Some insurers have no maximum age for enrollment, which is great for older adoptees. Others cut off new enrollments around age 10 or 12 for dogs (varies by breed) and a bit older for cats. If your pet is 8 or 9 and not yet insured, focus on providers that accept older pets. Also ensure that once enrolled, they guarantee lifetime renewals.
- Reputation & Customer Reviews: This is crucial. A plan might look great on paper but be a headache when claiming. Research what other pet owners say: Does the insurer actually pay claims quickly? Any issues with denying legitimate claims? Check recent reviews.
Make a short list (maybe 2–3 companies) that seem to meet your needs. For instance, you might narrow down to “Company A with $15k annual cap, Company B with unlimited cap” if both fit budget and cover what you want.
4. Get Quotes and Customize
Now, get official quotes from those finalists. Provide the same info for each (pet age, breed, ZIP code, etc.) to directly compare pricing. Most have online quote tools:
- Examine the default quote versus optional adjustments. Try tweaking the deductible or reimbursement to see price changes. Sometimes going from 90% to 80% reimbursement can save a lot with only a small difference in coverage outcome. Find the sweet spot you’re happy with.
- Note any discounts: e.g. multi-pet discount if you add another pet, or maybe an annual pay discount (paying for the year upfront might save ~5-10%). If you can afford to pay annually, this might be worth it for savings.
- Check for hidden fees or requirements: A few plans might have transaction fees or require things like an annual vet exam to keep coverage (actually many require this – you must keep up with routine vet visits, which you likely do anyway).
While quoting, also consider contacting your current vet to ask if they have any recommendations or experiences with certain insurers. Vets don’t typically deal directly with insurance, but they might have insight on which companies their clients have had good or bad experiences with when it comes to paying claims.
5. Evaluate Scenarios (Best vs Worst Case)
Before finalizing your choice, do a quick mental test: how would each plan perform in different scenarios? For example:
- If your pet has one big $10,000 surgery next year, Plan A with a $5k cap would leave you paying $5k yourself, while Plan B (unlimited) would cover almost all of it. Is Plan B worth the extra monthly cost for that peace of mind?
- If your pet has a moderate $1,000 illness this year, with Plan A (say $250 deductible, 80% cover) you’d pay $250 + 20% of the remaining $750 = $400 out of pocket and insurance pays $600. With Plan B (maybe $500 deductible, 90% cover and cheaper premium), you’d pay $500 + 10% of $500 = $550, insurance pays $450. Plan A saved you more in this scenario, but maybe Plan B saved you premium money over time.
- Worst case, if you never need to file a claim, which plan would you be least “bothered” to have paid for? Perhaps the cheaper one since it cost you less, or maybe the one with more coverage because it gave you more peace of mind.
Also consider the long term: Are premiums likely to rise a lot? Some companies have sharper annual increases than others. Searching online for “[Insurer Name] premium increase” can be eye-opening.
A plan that’s cheap now but doubles in a few years might not be the best. Many reviews will mention if people saw large hikes at renewal.
6. Check for Any Extra Perks or Limitations
As a final check, see if the plans offer any unique perks or have any quirks:
- Direct Pay Option: A perk some insurers have is paying vets directly so you don’t have to wait for reimbursement. If this is important to you, factor that in.
- Telehealth or Extra Services: Lately, a few insurers include extras like access to a 24/7 vet helpline or free telehealth consultations. This can be a nice bonus when comparing two closely matched plans.
- Coverage of Exam Fees: Surprisingly, some pet insurance plans don’t cover the exam/office visit fee by default. Others do cover it. An exam fee is often $50-$100 of the bill. Not a dealbreaker, but a plan that covers everything including exam fees will reimburse a bit more.
- Multi-pet on one plan or separate: If insuring multiple pets, some companies put them on one policy, others separate. Just ensure each pet’s coverage stands on its own. Check that a multi-pet discount is applied properly.
- Claim Limits or Penalties: Ensure there’s no limit on number of claims or any weird fine print like increased deductible after a certain number of claims (rare in pet insurance, but double-check).
At this stage, you likely have one plan that seems to fit best.
7. Read a Sample Policy & Finalize Enrollment
Before you hit “buy,” it’s wise to read the sample policy document (or at least save it). All reputable pet insurers will let you review the terms and conditions. Skim through and verify everything matches what you expect. Keep a copy of your policy details after purchase.
When enrolling, be honest and accurate about your pet’s medical history. Usually, you’ll provide vet records or answer questions. Don’t omit known issues – it won’t help you (they won’t be covered anyway, and you want everything transparent).
Once you have the policy, note down the waiting period end dates in your calendar – e.g. “After March 1, Fluffy is fully covered for illnesses.” And going forward, keep up with regular vet check-ups, as skipping annual vet visits could potentially affect claims since a condition might be considered pre-existing if it wasn’t caught earlier – insurers sometimes use gaps in vet visits against you, claiming a problem existed but wasn’t documented. Regular vet notes help prove when a condition started.
Conclusion: Confidently Picking Your Pet’s Plan
Selecting the right pet insurance plan comes down to understanding your pet’s needs, knowing what plans offer, and finding the best match within your budget. By following the steps in this guide – deciding on coverage needs, comparing options, and reviewing details – you’re setting yourself up for success. Remember, the “best” pet insurance is one that will reliably support you when you need it, and that you can comfortably maintain over your pet’s lifetime.
Once you’ve chosen a plan, you can rest easier knowing you’ve got a financial backup for your pet’s health. That means more focus on belly rubs and playtime, and less on worrying about “what if” scenarios. Your future self (and your pet) will thank you for taking these steps now.
Lastly, don’t forget to take advantage of other tools to save money for your family. Just as you’ve wisely protected your pet, tools like Kudos can protect your wallet on other fronts – for example, by finding you a better deal on auto insurance at no cost. Being a smart consumer in all areas gives you more freedom to care for your pet. Here’s to many happy, healthy years with your furry friend, now that you’ve got them covered!
FAQ: Your Pet Insurance Questions Answered
What are the top pet insurance companies in 2025?
Some of the best-known pet insurers (in terms of coverage and customer satisfaction) include Healthy Paws, Embrace, Pets Best, Trupanion, ASPCA Pet Health, Figo, Nationwide, and Lemonade, among others. Each has pros and cons.
Can I use my own vet with pet insurance?
Yes. Pet insurance doesn’t have networks, so you can use any licensed veterinarian in the U.S.. Since you pay the vet directly and then get reimbursed, the insurance company doesn’t dictate which vet you see.
Does pet insurance cover pre-existing conditions?
Unfortunately, no – pre-existing conditions are excluded by all pet insurance providers. A condition is generally deemed pre-existing if it was evident before your coverage started (or during the waiting period).
Will my premium go up if I make a lot of claims?
Typically, no. Pet insurance premiums aren’t like car insurance – they don’t increase because you filed claims. They do, however, tend to go up over time due to your pet’s age and overall inflation in vet costs. So you can expect premiums to rise a bit each year as your pet gets older (and as vet fees increase in general).
What if pet insurance isn’t available in my state?
Pet insurance is available in most states, but occasionally a specific company might not operate in one (e.g. a newer insurer still rolling out in certain states). If a company you wanted doesn’t offer policies in your state, you’ll have to choose an alternative.
Double the Cash, Zero the Worry
Looking for consistent rewards without the hassle? The Citi Double Cash® Card rewards you twice: 1% when you buy, another 1% when you pay—for a total 2% cash back on every purchase with no categories to track. Plus, smart balance transfer options help you take control of existing debt. Simple, powerful, perfect for today's savvy spenders.
Editorial Disclosure: Opinions expressed here are those of Kudos alone, not those of any bank, credit card issuer, hotel, airline, or other entity. This content has not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any of the entities included within the post.
